Are You Giving Pets As Christmas Gifts? Ask Yourself These Questions First

They tied a ribbon to his collar and tucked him in a basket under the tree. But when Christmas morning came, the little boy barely looked at Riley, the adorable pup waiting patiently for love and attention. He didn’t want to play with him or hold him. Later that evening, Riley was left alone in the city, cold, scared, and unwanted.

While the story above is fictional, it mirrors a very real problem that happens far too often during the holidays. Movies and commercials often paint a picture of joy when giving pets as Christmas gifts, but in reality, it can lead to heartbreak. As heartwarming as the idea sounds, pets are living beings, not toys, and their needs last long after the wrapping paper is gone.

Let’s explore why pets do not always make good gifts and what thoughtful steps you can take if you’re considering welcoming a new furry friend into someone’s life this holiday season.

#1: Does the recipient really want a new pet?

Many people adore the idea of having a cuddly puppy or kitten, but not everyone is ready for the real-life commitment that comes with it. Cute holiday moments can fade quickly when daily responsibilities, such as feeding, training, and vet visits, take over.

Before giving a pet as a Christmas gift, have an honest conversation with the recipient. Ask them if they genuinely want and are prepared for the responsibility. Pets require years of care, attention, and financial commitment. Without readiness, the animal may end up in a shelter, an outcome no one wants.

#2: Is the recipient ready for a new pet emotionally?

Sometimes people consider pets as gifts to help a loved one heal from the loss of a previous pet. While the thought is kind, grief is deeply personal. Some need time to mourn before they can open their hearts again.

If you know someone who’s grieving, express your love and support instead. Perhaps consider gifting a photo frame of their beloved pet or making a donation to a local animal shelter in their pet’s name. These gestures can be healing without the pressure of a new responsibility.

#3: If the recipient is ready for a pet, why does she not have one yet?

If you know your potential giftee is a dog and cat lover who wants a new pet, consider why she does not yet have one. Lack of time, personal reasons, financial constraints, a potential move, lack of space, or upcoming travel plans can push back the time frame on adopting a new pet.

A new puppy or kitten can be a burden financially with wellness veterinary visits for vaccination boosters, and a huge time commitment with training and socializing. Friends and family may not always share their reasons for waiting, which is precisely why you shouldn't give pets as gifts without fully understanding their situation.

Even with the best intentions, surprising someone with a pet can create stress rather than joy if they aren’t completely ready for the responsibility.

#4 Should you make this decision for someone else?

If the gift is for your child and you’re prepared to take on the long-term care, that’s one thing. But if the recipient is a friend, extended family member, or someone you don’t live with, you might not know their full situation.

Choosing a pet is a very personal decision, one that should never be made for someone else. Every family has unique needs, routines, and preferences. Surprising someone with a pet as a gift may lead to stress or resentment rather than joy.

#5: Are you sure everyone is on board with getting a new pet as a gift?

Even if your niece or nephew dreams of a puppy, their parents may disagree. Bringing a pet into someone’s home without consent can create tension and conflict. Pets are a long-term commitment, often 10 to 15 years or more, and everyone involved must be ready for that responsibility.

This is another reason why you shouldn't give pets as gifts without discussing it with the entire household first. Before giving pets as gifts, ensure the whole family supports the idea and is prepared to provide a loving and stable home.

#6: Are the holidays the best time to welcome a new pet into the family?

The holidays are one of the most chaotic and hectic times of the year, and welcoming a new pet into your family only adds to the extra stress. Your new pet may not receive the attention she deserves, since you will be busy with holiday gatherings and commitments.

Pets thrive on routine, which is often nonexistent during the holidays, leading to a poor start to their acclimation. For anyone who plans on welcoming a new pet into their family, the holidays are not the best time. Choose a time when you can train, bond, and accustom your new pet to her new life.

Consider reading these helpful articles to help you understand cat and dog body language before you welcome one into your home:

• Deciphering Dog Body Language: What Your Pup Is Telling You

• Understanding Cat Communication and What Your Feline Wants

Frequently asked questions

1. Is it ever okay to give a pet as a gift?

Yes, but only when the recipient has expressed a clear desire and readiness for a pet. Giving pets as Christmas gifts can be a thoughtful idea if the person receiving the animal is fully prepared for the responsibility.

2. What’s a better alternative to surprising someone with a pet?

Provide supplies such as food bowls, toys, or gift cards to cover adoption fees. This allows your loved one to prepare properly and select a pet when the time is right.

3. What should I do if I already gave a pet as a gift and it’s not working out?

Reach out to a trusted vet in Billings, MT, or an animal shelter for advice. It’s better to find a responsible solution than to let the pet suffer.

4. Where can I find support for a new pet in Billings, MT?

Our compassionate team at Billings Animal Family Hospital is here to help with preventive care, vaccinations, and behavior guidance.

5. Why isn’t it always a good idea to give pets as Christmas gifts?

Giving pets as Christmas gifts can backfire if the recipient isn’t ready for the responsibility. The holidays are often busy and stressful, making it challenging for pets to adjust to their new homes.

A thoughtful holiday reminder

The holidays are about love, family, and compassion. Before giving pets as Christmas gifts, think about the lifelong commitment involved. If you’re truly ready to bring a pet into your home, we’ll be here to help every step of the way.

Schedule your pet’s first wellness visit or reach out through our Contact Page. Don’t forget to download our free Emergency Vet Contact Card, a helpful resource for every pet parent in Billings, MT.

If your pet ever needs urgent care, call us at (406) 245-4772. From all of us at Billings Animal Family Hospital, we wish you and your furry family members a safe and joyful holiday season!